|
DECISIONS AND ORDERS
GENERAL ORDERS ISSUED
UNDER THE FIRE & POLICE ARBITRATION STATUTE
2013
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
2012-ULPC-523
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
4/02/2013
|
IAFF, Local 176
|
City's Motion to Dismiss ULPC Granted; issue involved retirees from the unit
|
| 2012-ULPC-521
|
|
|
Ada
Ada
Tulsa
Jenks
|
4/02/2013
|
IAFF, Local 2298
IAFF, Local 176
FOP, Lodge 146
|
Each of these cities filed a Motion to Dismiss Charges based on the allegation that PERB cannot adjudicate these cases to conclusion because the Board does not exist after November 1, 2012 (due to the enactment of two amendments during the last Legislative Session).
Another issue addressed was an Objection to Jurisdiction of PERB and to Delay Proceedings until the Board has five board members.
|
2012
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
2011-ULPC-505
|
|
|
Lawton
|
01/12/12
|
IUPA, Local 24
|
Nepotism Issue
|
|
2011-ULPC-503
|
Cleveland Co District Court
|
CV-2012-396-W
|
Norman
|
3/08/12
|
FOP, Lodge 122
|
Polygraph Test
|
|
2011-ULPC-511
|
|
|
Bixby
|
4/12/12
|
IAFF, Local 2651
|
Expired interest arbitration date
|
|
2011-ULPC-510
|
Oklahoma Co District Court
Ok Supreme Court
|
CV-2012-1229
No. 111520
|
McAlester
|
5/17/12
|
IAFF, Local 2284
|
Refusing to engage in grievance arbitration
|
|
2011-ULPC-503
|
|
|
Norman
|
6/21/12
|
FOP, Lodge 122
|
Motion to Clarify/Vacate PERB Order
|
|
2011-ULPC-509
|
Oklahoma Co District Court
|
CV-2012-1881
|
Tulsa
|
8/9/12
|
IAFF, Local 176
|
Political Activity concerning employee campaigning through Union's Political Action Committee
|
|
2012-ULPC-520
|
|
|
Darrell Martin (firefighter) v City of Tulsa & IAFF, Local 176
|
10/11/12
|
Local 176
|
Issue involving recoup of overpayments made to an individual employee
|
2011
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
2010-ULPC-493
|
|
|
OKC
|
03/10/11
|
IAFF, Local 157
|
Failing to bargain in good faith by unilateral changes in the contract
|
|
2010-ULPC-490
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
03/10/11
|
FOP, Lodge 93
|
Deferral to Arbitration Award re laying off of officers in wrong order
|
|
2010-ULPC-497&
497CC
|
|
|
McAlester
|
05/12/11
|
IAFF, Local 2284
|
Failing to negotiate for a new contract
|
|
2011-ULPC-504
|
|
|
Stillwater
|
10/13/11
|
FOP, Lodge 102
|
Direct Dealing
|
|
2011-RC-12432PD
|
|
|
Dibble
|
10/13/2011
|
FOP, Lodge 208
|
Unit Clarification regarding Administrative Assistant
|
2010
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
00444
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
2/11/10
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Consent Order Issued
|
|
00479
|
|
|
Oklahoma City
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 157
|
Refusing to Comply With Arbitrator Award
|
|
2009-ULPC-480
|
Dist Ct Tulsa Co
|
CV-2010-01192
|
Tulsa
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 176
|
Failing to Arbitrate Issue of Terminated Employee
|
|
2009-ULPC-481
|
|
|
Broken Arrow
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 2551
|
Summary Judgment Denied, Dave Wooden Dismissed As Respondent
|
|
2009-ULPC-481
|
|
|
Broken Arrow
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 2551
|
Retaliation, ULPC Dismissed
|
|
2010-ULPC-487
|
|
|
Broken Arrow
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 2551
|
Interfering With Union Rights
|
|
2010-ULPC-492
|
|
|
Chickasha
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 2041
|
Unilateral Changes
|
|
2010-ULPC-493
|
|
|
Oklahoma City
|
9/17/10
|
IAFF, Local 157
|
Last Best Offer, City's Motion to Dismiss Denied
|
2009
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
00473
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
2/24/09
|
FOP, Lodge 93
|
Pre-Arbitration Deferral
|
|
00474
|
|
|
Yukon
|
2/24/09
|
FOP, Lodge 173
|
Subjects of Arbitrability
|
|
00445
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
4/09/09
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Consent Agreement
|
|
00475
|
|
|
Choctaw
|
4/20/09
|
Jeff Lane
|
Regarding City's Motion to Dismiss
|
|
00469
|
|
|
Lawton
|
6/10/09
|
IAFF, Local 1882
|
Circumvention of City's bargaining representatives
|
|
00478
|
|
|
Norman
|
6/17/09
|
FOP, Lodge 122
|
Addressing the issue of compliance with an arbitration award
|
2008
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
12417-D
|
|
|
Broken Bow
|
01/16/08
|
IAFF, Local 2962
|
Administrative Assistant
|
|
00448
|
|
|
OKC
|
02/25/08
|
FOP, Lodge 123
|
Retaliatory Actions
|
|
00445
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
03/24/08
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Direct Dealing
|
|
00444
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
05/08/08
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Summary Judgment regarding "acting in an official capacity" as related to unfair labor practices
|
|
12417-D
|
|
|
Broken Bow
|
05/08/08
|
IAFF, Local 2962
|
Defunct Union
|
|
12417-D
|
|
|
Broken Bow
|
05/08/08
|
IAFF, Local 2962
|
Sanctions
|
|
00448
|
|
|
OKC
|
08/14/08
|
FOP, Lodge 123
|
Retalitory Actions; Settlement Agreement
|
|
00466
|
|
|
Muskogee
|
08/27/08
|
IAFF, Local 57
|
No signed contract
|
|
00467
|
|
|
Nicoma Park
|
08/27/08
|
Police Officer Christopher Hudgens
|
Summary Judgment regarding confidentiality
|
2007
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
00443
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
02/12/07
|
IAFF, Local 1628
|
Defer to Arbitration
|
|
00439
|
|
|
Warr Acres
|
03/05/07
|
IAFF, Local 2374
|
Timely notice given to bargain
|
|
00440
|
|
|
Hugo
|
04/09/07
|
IAFF, Local 3199
|
Unilateral Changes in mandatory subjects of bargaining
|
|
00438
|
|
|
Warr Acres
|
04/09/07
|
FOP, Lodge 145
|
Subpoena for minutes of executive session
|
|
00431
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
04/16/07
|
FOP, Lodge 93
|
Request for Meeting Reschedule
|
|
00438
|
|
|
Warr Acres
|
04/16/07
|
FOP, Lodge 145
|
Motion for Protective Order
|
|
00444
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
05/23/07
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Motion to Dismiss James Collard, Respondent
|
|
00445
|
|
|
Shawnee
|
05/23/07
|
IUPA, Local 3
|
Motion to Dismiss James Collard, Respondent
|
|
12415
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
07/23/07
|
IAFF, Local 176
|
Unit Clarification regarding probationary firefighters
|
|
00388
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
09/17/07
|
FOP, Lodge 39
|
Bargaining in good faith & labeling of confidential files
|
|
00431
|
|
|
Tulsa
|
10/18/07
|
FOP, Lodge 93
|
Direct Dealing
|
|
00440
|
|
|
Hugo
|
10/19/07
|
IAFF, Local 3199
|
Bargaining in good faith
|
|
00446
|
|
|
Broken Bow
|
10/31/07
|
IAFF, Local 2962
|
Summary Judgment on question of abandonment
|
|
00446
|
|
|
Broken Bow
|
10/31/07
|
IAFF, Local 2962
|
Summary Judgment on designated Administrative Assistant
|
|
00449
|
|
|
Warr Acres
|
12/12/07
|
IAFF, Local 2374
|
Summary Judgment regarding contract agreement
|
2006
|
Case Number
|
Appeals
|
|
City
|
Date
|
Union Involved
|
Subject Matter
|
|
00421
|
OK Supreme Ct
Certiorari Denied
Cleveland Dist Ct
|
DF-105599
105,599
CJ-06-1069
|
Norman
|
06/08/06
|
FOP, Lodge 122
|
Refusing to bargain in good faith
|
|
00424
|
|
|
Norman
|
02/16/06
|
IAFF, Local 2067
|
Circumventing the Bargaining Agent
|
|
00432
|
|
|
OKC
|
08/21/06
|
FOP, Lodge 123
|
Weingarten Rights regarding pre-polygraph interview
|
|
00434
|
OK Dist Ct
|
CJ-2006-8889
|
Stillwater
|
12/14/2006
|
IAFF, Local 2095
|
Unfair Disciplinary Action
|
UNDER THE MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT (MECBA) 2006-current
|
Case No.
|
Appeals
|
|
Union/City Involved
|
Date
|
Subject Matter
|
|
M1400
|
|
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
12/14/06
|
Motion for Certification in the City of Lawton
|
|
M1400
|
|
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
12/14/06
|
Motion to Disqualify Board Member Gooch
|
|
M1400
|
|
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
03/05/07
|
Definition of Supervisory & Confidential Employees
|
|
004-PPC
|
|
|
AFSCME & FOP v OKC
|
02/25/08
|
Transfer of Duties
|
|
010-PPC
|
|
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
12/19/08
|
Unilateral Bargaining regarding pension contributions
|
|
011-PPC
|
|
|
IBEW v Stillwater
|
04/20/09
|
Regarding City's Motion to Dismiss
|
|
012-PPC
|
|
|
CWA v Stillwater
|
04/20.09
|
Regarding City's Motion to Dismiss
|
|
010-PPC
|
Dist Ct Comanche Co
|
CJ-2009-680
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
06/26/09
|
Regarding duty to bargain with respect to the existing retirement system
|
|
2009-PPC-013M
|
|
|
AFSCME v Tulsa
|
09/17/10
|
Regarding honoring a memorandum of understanding
|
|
2009-PPC-014
|
|
|
Lawton v AFSCME
|
09/27/10
|
Regarding regressive bargaining
|
|
2009-PPC-016
|
Dist Ct OK Co
|
CV-2010-1368
|
IBEW v Stillwater
|
09/17/10
|
Regarding expired contract & "evergreen" clause
|
|
2010-PPC-018
|
|
|
AFSCME v Norman
|
01/13/11
|
Order Granting City's Motion to Quash Subpoena
|
|
2010-PPC-018
|
|
|
AFSCME v Norman & John Bowman
|
05/12/11
|
Order Granting Union Summary Judgment regarding unilateral bargaining for Union's use of cell phone during business hours and Granting Summary Judgment to John Bowman
|
UNIT CLARIFICATION CASES UNDER MECBA
|
M1402
|
AFSCME v Enid
|
07/24/06
|
Enid's Disputed Positions involving confidential employees
|
|
M1401
|
AFSCME v Moore
|
03/05/07
|
Position of Building Official & Public Safety Dispatch Supervisor
|
|
M1402
|
AFSCME v Enid
|
04/06/07
|
Position of Enid's "911 Supervisors" included in unit
|
|
M1400
|
AFSCME v Lawton
|
12/19/07
|
Disputed Employee Positions in the City of Lawton
|
|
M1405
|
CWA v Broken Arrow
|
04/24/09
|
Regarding Employee Supervisory Positions
|
|
M1410
|
AFSCME v Tulsa
|
05/26/09
|
Regarding confidential employees (Medical Assistant & Medical/Radiology Technician)
|
|
M1410
|
AFSCME v Tulsa
|
09/17/10
|
Regarding Administrative Techs & Office Techs
|
|
M1414
|
AFSCME v Tulsa
|
09/17/10
|
Regarding Information Technology/Information System Unit
|
1986-2005 DECISIONS AND ORDERS
|
